Auto Trader

Car Dealer Reviews is an
official partner of Auto Trader


14 reviews from our car dealer reviews community
Leave a review for Carnegie Cars
Leave a review

14 reviews from our car dealer reviews community

Leave a review for Carnegie Cars
Leave a review
What is a verified review?
Reviewer has successfully provided either proof of ID or proof of purchase
Learn More
"Knowingly sold car with bald tyre"
1.8 out of 5 stars
Dealer's knowledgeable
Vehicle cleanliness
Value for money
Resolving issues

I didn't act on this at the time as I was just glad to get everything sorted out after days of messing around, but some photos came up in my memories today from 3 years ago and I was reminded of the following: The car that I had purchased had its MOT retest just days before. After owning the car for less than 48 hours, I had a flat tyre. With no spare, I had to call the AA. The AA man couldn't believe it when he saw that the flat tyre was BALD with wire sticking out of it (an automatic 3 points if stopped by the police). It would have been impossible for the car to have passed its MOT retest with that tyre, so the only conclusion is that Carnegie Cars knowingly took the legal tyre off, replaced it with a bald one and hoped that I wouldn't notice. Dodgy, avoid.

Get Car Finance

Reviewer has confirmed their email address

+3 Found this review helpful
"AVOID"
1 out of 5 stars
Dealer's knowledgeable
Vehicle cleanliness
Value for money
Resolving issues

Bought a car from Carnegie Cars, took weeks before I got it as it failed it’s MOT on a lot of things. Apparently he fixed everything. When I got the car it was back within a week with a broken spring. He replaced the steering rack, but I later found out he uses cheap parts to fix his cars. Steering rack went again and I was outside my warranty. I had the car less than a year and I had to get rid of it. I would avoid using Carnegie cars Jeff is a cowboy and is only interested in putting money in his pockets, doesn’t care about his customers at all.

"No Hard sell. Great Customer Service."
5 out of 5 stars
Dealer's knowledgeable
Vehicle cleanliness
Value for money
Resolving issues

My husband and I purchased a Mercedes from Carnaigie Cars. Customer Service was great. No hard sell. Jeff was very helpful and very knowledgable and assisted us all the way with the sale. Car is marvelous . I would not hesitate buying again from here. A pleasure to do business with.

"Stellar dealer"
5 out of 5 stars
Dealer's knowledgeable
Vehicle cleanliness
Value for money
Resolving issues

Jeff offers fantastic value for money on clean and sound cars. He is also very helpful and knowledegable about vehicle finance. First class, hassle free service from Carnegie Cars.

Get Car Finance

Reviewer has confirmed their email address

+0 Found this review helpful
"Fantastic service"
5 out of 5 stars
Dealer's knowledgeable
Vehicle cleanliness
Value for money
Resolving issues

Just recently bought a car from Carnegie Cars, Jeff was fantastic no pressure to buy the whole experience was fantastic would recommend to friends and family and any one looking for a used car. Thank you jeff

Get Car Finance

Reviewer has confirmed their email address

+0 Found this review helpful
"Fab deal great service."
5 out of 5 stars
Dealer's knowledgeable
Vehicle cleanliness
Value for money
Resolving issues

Just got a great deal on a fab car. Jeff is a gentleman put no pressure on me to buy gave great advice and was so helpfull. I would highly recommend Carnegie Cars.

"Brilliant garage"
5 out of 5 stars
Dealer's knowledgeable
Vehicle cleanliness
Value for money
Resolving issues

Got a Nissan note n Tec fab car no problems and Jeff at Carneige Cars was very pleasant and helpful would definitely recommend this garage thank you so much Jeff much appreciated.

"1ST CLASS SERVICE FROM START TO FINISH"
5 out of 5 stars
Dealer's knowledgeable
Vehicle cleanliness
Value for money
Resolving issues

SO GLAD I FOUND THIS GARAGE. THE SERVICE WAS BRILLIANT. CAR WAS EXACTLY AS ADVERTISED. THE STAFF WERE VERY FRIENDLY PROFESSIONAL AND HELPFUL. THEY SORTED OUT THE FINANCE AND THE CAR FOR ME VERY QUICKLY, I WOULD RECOMMEND CARNEGIE CARS WITHOUT HESITATION.

"Great service"
5 out of 5 stars
Dealer's knowledgeable
Vehicle cleanliness
Value for money
Resolving issues

Bought our car over a month ago from Carnegie Cars and discovered a leak from the radiator last week. Phoned up and told to bring the car in. Just picked it up with new unit fitted. Good accredited business and easy to deal with. Wouldn't hesitate to go back ! Many thanks.

Get Car Finance

Reviewer has confirmed their email address

+0 Found this review helpful
"AVOID"
1 out of 5 stars
Dealer's knowledgeable
Vehicle cleanliness
Value for money
Resolving issues

AVOID! DO NOT GO NEAR THIS GARAGE DO NOT BUY CARS FROM HERE EITHER. False promises for repairs, they sold me a car knowing it had fault when we purchased the car we never got it that day. Was recalled to Nissan and wasn't told about fault all you get is attitude from the manager Jeff at Carnegie Cars.

Auto Trader

Car Dealer Reviews is an official partner of Auto Trader

Get Car Finance

CDR Logo Transparent
Auto Trader Get a Quote

Want a quote for PPF? Highly competitive quotes on Paint Protection Film for your car

Get Car Finance

CDR Logo Transparent

Dealership Information

Carnegie Cars is an Independent dealership that is based in Dunfermline. If you’re the owner or employee of this business, please send us a little bit of information about your dealership and why customers should come and visit.

Alternatively, if you’re a customer and you’ve had an experience at this dealership, please leave a review below.

Manufacturers: Sells a variety of makes and models
Independent Dealership

Services available
Car Hire
Car Leasing
Car Repairs
Car Sourcing
Finance
GAP Insurance
Motorbike Sales
New Car Sales
Part Exchange
Sell Your Car
Servicing
Used Car Sales
Van Sales
Warranty
Ratings
14 reviews4.2 out of 5 stars — Rated Very Good
Excellent
11
Very Good
0
Average
0
Poor
1
Terrible
2

Add Review

  • Submit new information

  • Contact Information

    Address

    Carnegie Cars
    209 Baldridgeburn
    Dunfermline
    Fife
    KY12 9EG

    Get in touch

    01383 223741
    http://www.carnegiecars.co.uk

    Opening times

    Sorry, we don't have opening times for this dealership

    If you're the business owner, you can update this page by getting in touch with us at info@cardealerreviews.co.uk

    Dealership Statistics

    78%
    Would recommend this dealer to family and friends
    0%
    Percent of reviews responded to by this dealer

    Additional Information About Carnegie Cars

    Company Formed: XXXXXXXXXX
    Company Registration: XXXXXXXXXX
    Dealer Group: XXXXXXXXXX
    Directors: XXXXXXXXXX
    FCA Ref: XXXXXXXXXX
    FCAStatus: XXXXXXXXXX
    Premises Type: XXXXXXXXXX
    Registered Name: XXXXXXXXXX
    VAT Number: XXXXXXXXXX


    Are we missing anything?
    You can help complete this section by emailing us any additional details.

    Submit new information

    Working with Car Dealer Reviews

    We offer UK dealerships an excellent opportunity to collect those all important reviews on your behalf for as little as £79 + VAT per month.

    Learn more about how our service works below.

    Find out more